When Yellow Means Green

Our Kindergartner (and youngest child) is very proud of “staying on green” at school.  This was never a priority for his siblings.  They talked and did plenty of other disruptive things.  They weren’t problem children, but they typically weren’t going to qualify for the Good Citizenship Award at the end of the year either.

Hal, on the other hand, was getting a green sticker on his take-home calendar every single day.  These stickers were typically green smileys.  Sometimes it would be just a green dot made by a marker.  Something, each day, to signify that he had been well behaved.

And then… and then… one day, we saw this:



A… yellow… sticker!

Shocked, I called Hal into the room.  “What’s this, Sweetheart?” I asked him, careful to keep the question curious, not judgmental.

He looked confused.

“Did you get a mark?!” I asked in mock dismay.

He studied the sheet for a minute.

“Mommy,” he finally said, pointing to the yellow sticker.  “Mommy, I think that that day was supposed to be green.”

“No, honey.  It’s yellow.  Do you remember what you did that day?”

“No, Mommy.  I think it was supposed to be green.  You see?  It has a smiley face.  So I think she ran out of green stickers.  I was still on green.”

“No, sweetheart.  When she doesn’t have a green sticker, she uses a green marker.  See?  Like all these other days.”

“But Mommy,” he said, earnestly trying to make his point.  “Look.  It’s got a smiley face.  If it was supposed to be for yellow, it’d have a straight line.” (At this, he moved his finger straight across his lips).

“Honey, it means you were on yellow.  She just has a book of stickers with all different colors and they all have smiley faces.”

He looked distressed.  “But why would she put a smiley sticker for yellow?”

“It’s ok, sweetie.  If the worst thing you ever do in your life is get a yellow sticker, we’ll be doing just fine.  Ok?”


“Really, sweetheart.  It’s ok.”

He left the room with his head hung low, not convinced at all that it would be ok.  And also not convinced that that yellow smiley was really yellow.


4 thoughts on “When Yellow Means Green

    • I’ve seen the packet of stickers at Wal-Mart that the teacher is probably using. It has thousands of little circular stickers. Several of the sheets are smileys of all different colors (green, yellow, red, blue, purple, orange). So she’s just using those because it’s quick and easy. They aren’t custom designed for behavior reporting… that said, it definitely threw off my kid!

    • As I said to Marissa above, I know what Wal-Mart purchased book of stickers the teacher was using. I’ve seen it. I’m not going to fault her because she probably didn’t think about how it could be interpreted (I didn’t until I listened to Hal’s argument) and the calendar is intended more for the parents than the children, and we had no trouble understanding what it was telling us.

      That said, it is fairly confusing now that I think about it. Just imagine how confusing a red smiley would be?!

Did this strike a chord with you? Tell me about it!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s